American Idol Season 9: Did Siobhan Magnus Peak to Early?
I am a big fan of Siobhan and want her to win, but since Through The Fire it seems like she’s holding back, will that affect her chances to compete with others like Crystal and Lee?
Recommended Readings
- American Idol: Siobhan Magnus Shoves Off | Hecklerspray
- American Idol 2010: Siobhan Magnus gets new tattoo @ Unreality TV
- “Showboat Magnus” is the only Siobhan insult Simon didn’t think of : Beatweek Magazine
- American Idol: Siobhan Magnus, Lee Dewyze, Michael Lynche, & Crystal Bowersox’s New Tattoos | Reality TV Magazine
- Siobhan Magnus Enters The House Of The Rising Sun Once More On ‘Ellen’ « Idolator: Music News, Reviews, And Gossip
Tagged with: siobhan
Filed under: Season 9
I think the judges criticism got to her… they hammered into her head that the screaming was bad, and ever since then… shes been lost. She has a tremendous voice… and thru parts of that song i almost heard it… but she just seems to be defeated. Simon needs to quit about her outfits….yes shes quirky, get over it…I like her the best.. i want her to win… i hope she gets her confidence back!
She’s been over taken by the others. She was good at the beginning but hasn’t improved any more, unlike the others who’ve all come on miles since the show started. I never thought she was on the same level as Crystal and Lee.
She seems to have fallen off track over the last few weeks. While others are improving. Hope she makes it to Top 5.
I find the judges are relentless on their criticism of her week after week, I thought her last performance was the best of the night, yet she was blasted for it. I feel the judges are biased in favor of Chrystal and Lee, they can do no wrong. Siobhan is my favorite.
yea her performances from 4-5 weeks ago were way better than her recent ones. i would have thought she was number 2 behind crystal, but i think lee has taken over that spot
YESSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSp. And they give her too much time after ripping her to lisp a self indulgent comment.