Has anyone ever been told no by Simon on their original audition of American Idol and then won?
I was thinking about how selective simon is on american idol auditions and wondered if he had ever messed up
Recommended Readings
- How can Simon Cowell be at the American Idol auditions and at the … | TwitterGlitter.com
- What Are Judges of American Idol and Other Talent Auditions Looking For | Mindtalk Video Review
- American Idol Auditions: Las Vegas (Season 4) | American Worst Idol
- American Idol Results: Andrew Garcia, Katie Stevens Ousted In Double Elimination | Neon Limelight – Exclusive Music News, Artist Interviews, Reviews, Photos!
- ‘American Idol’: Top 9, Take 2, As Andrew Garcia And Katie Stevens Exit « Idolator: Music News, Reviews, And Gossip
Tagged with: American Idol • american idol auditions
Filed under: American Idol Season
He told Taylor Hicks no, I think. But then, as is turns out he was kind of right about Taylor Hicks because he’s done the worst of any American Idol and sold the least. He didn’t tell Jennifer Hudson no, he told her to dress better and lose weight. He also told her he thought she’d be great for Broadway or musicals and thought she’d be more of a success if she tried that route first. She got voted off pretty early because she was wearing some outrageous hairstyles and clothes, they were just really ugly and distracting. She fixed herself up, went into a musical and got a career. So looks like Simon was right on that point too. The thing about Simon Cowell is he’s a successful music producer, he knows what will sell and what won’t.
Except Taylor Hicks
He told Jennifer Hudson no. She didnt win but I bet he’s eating his words now.
Also Clay Aiken, but he was the runner up.