If you could change the positions of the Top 12 contestants in American Idol Season 5?
If you could change the positions of the top 12 contestants in American Idol Season 5 from the first person voted off until the winner how would your outcome be?
Mine would be:
12. Melissa McGhee
11. Taylor Hicks
10. Lisa Tucker
9. Kevin Covais
8. Kellie Pickler
7. Ace Young
6. Mandisa Hundley
5. Paris Bennett
4. Bucky Covington
3. Elliott Yamin
2. Katharine McPhee
1. Chris Daughtry
Tagged with: ace • American Idol • american idol season 5 • bucky covington • chris daughtry • first person • katharine mcphee • kellie pickler • lisa tucker • mandisa • melissa mcghee • paris bennett • taylor hicks
Filed under: Season 5
12. Lisa Tucker
11. Kevin Covais
10. Melissa McGhee
9. Kellie Pickler
8. Taylor Hicks
7. Mandisa Hundley
6. Ace Young
5. Bucky Covington
4. Paris Bennett
3. Elliott Yamin
2. Katharine McPhee
1. Chris Daughtry
I was also upset when Daughtry got voted off and I sure am glad he now has a very successful career, I would’ve gladly replaced Lisa with Ayla for the Top 12 and if Ayla made the Top 12 I would’ve liked to see her be at least in the Top 7
I feel your pain. I cried the night that Chris Daughtry was voted off American Idol. I am a huge fan of his now and he is doing awesome. He didnt need Idol to support his career. He is awesome on his own. Sure Idol exposed him and got him going, but he doesnt need them anymore and that is awesome. Taylor Hicks and Katharine McPhee are always going to need Idol to support them. It is their claim to fame. Chris Daughtrys claim to fame could be that he was voted off Idol and is still more successful that the top two finishers that season. GO DAUGHTRY!!!
12. Taylor Hicks
11. Kevin Covais
10.Melissa McGhee
9.Lisa Tucker
8.Mandisa Hundley
7.Bucky Covington
6.Paris Bennett
5.Kelly Pickler
4.Ace Young
3 Elliot Yamin
2.Katherine Mcphee
1.Chris Daughtry